Skip to content 
Edward Kieswetter’s salary of R11.71 million in the 2023/24 financial year at the South African Revenue Service (SARS) raised eyebrows. It’s an 83.4% jump from the previous year. This figure, detailed in SARS’s annual report, fuels debates about public sector pay, especially for a leader tasked with rebuilding a critical institution. Kieswetter, who returned from retirement in 2019, has driven SARS to collect a record R1.7 trillion in tax revenue despite economic stagnation. His compensation reflects results—but is it justified?
This article unpacks Kieswetter’s salary, his transformative leadership, the SARS turnaround, and practical lessons for professionals. Expect actionable insights on tax compliance, leadership strategies, and financial planning, all grounded in Kieswetter’s story.
Kieswetter’s Career: From SARS to Private Sector and Back
Edward Kieswetter’s journey to SARS Commissioner is a tale of grit and expertise. Born in South Africa, he earned a BCom from the University of Cape Town and later an MBA from Henley Business School. His early career at SARS, starting in 2004, saw him rise to Senior Deputy Commissioner under Pravin Gordhan. Kieswetter was instrumental in modernizing tax systems, boosting compliance, and fighting illicit trade. SARS, in the 2000s, was a global model, keeping illicit cigarette trade below 10% through dedicated enforcement units.
In 2009, Kieswetter left SARS for the private sector, joining Alexander Forbes as Group CEO. There, he stabilized a struggling firm, growing its assets under management to over R300 billion by 2018. His leadership blended data-driven decisions with employee engagement, a hallmark of his style. But SARS called again. In 2019, President Cyril Ramaphosa tapped Kieswetter to return as Commissioner. State capture had gutted SARS, and Kieswetter faced a daunting task: rebuild an institution hollowed out by corruption and mismanagement.
Kieswetter’s return wasn’t just a homecoming. It was a mission. He brought decades of experience, a track record of turnarounds, and a deep understanding of SARS’s DNA. His salary would later reflect this expertise, but first, he had to confront a broken system.
The Fall of SARS: State Capture’s Devastating Impact
SARS wasn’t always a shadow of itself. Under Pravin Gordhan (1999-2009), it was a powerhouse. Tax collection funded South Africa’s democratic state, and enforcement units cracked down on tax evasion and illicit trade. By 2009, SARS was a global benchmark, with robust systems and skilled staff. Then, state capture struck.
From 2014 to 2018, under President Jacob Zuma, SARS was systematically undermined. The Nugent Commission, established to investigate SARS’s decline, revealed shocking details. Key leaders were sidelined, enforcement units dismantled, and skilled staff pushed out. Illicit trade surged—cigarette smuggling alone grew from 10% to 30% of the market by 2018. The COVID-19 cigarette ban pushed this to 60% by 2020, costing billions in lost revenue. SARS’s ability to collect taxes and enforce compliance crumbled.
Kieswetter inherited this mess in 2019. The Nugent Commission described SARS as “an unfortunate casualty” of state capture. Staff morale was low. Systems were outdated. Public trust was eroded. Kieswetter’s mandate was clear: restore SARS to its former glory. His salary, later scrutinized, was tied to this high-stakes mission.
Edward Kieswetter’s Salary: Breaking Down the R11.71 Million
The Numbers Behind the Paycheck
Edward Kieswetter’s salary of R11.71 million in 2023/24 is a lightning rod for debate. According to SARS’s 2023/24 annual report, this marked an 83.4% increase from R6.39 million the previous year. Over five years (2019-2024), Kieswetter earned R37.27 million, averaging R7.45 million annually. The 2023/24 spike likely includes performance bonuses, pension contributions, and adjustments for inflation or results.
How does this compare? The average South African CEO earns R5-10 million annually, per PwC’s 2023 Executive Pay Report. Public sector leaders, like Eskom’s CEO (R7.1 million in 2023), earn less than Kieswetter but still draw scrutiny. Kieswetter’s pay aligns with private-sector benchmarks for turnarounds, yet public sector salaries face harsher judgment. Critics argue R11.71 million is excessive in a country with 32.9% unemployment (Stats SA, 2024). Supporters counter that Kieswetter’s results—R1.7 trillion in revenue—justify the cost.
What’s in Edward Kieswetter’s Salary?
Public sector salaries often include:
- Base Pay: Likely R8-9 million, reflecting Kieswetter’s seniority.
- Performance Bonuses: Tied to revenue targets or reform milestones.
- Pension and Benefits: Standard for executives, boosting total compensation.
The 83.4% increase raises questions. Was it a one-off bonus for record revenue? Or a correction for prior underpayment? SARS hasn’t disclosed specifics, but the jump coincides with unprecedented tax collection in a tough economy.
Contextualizing the Pay
South Africa’s Gini coefficient, at 0.63, signals extreme inequality (World Bank, 2023). Kieswetter’s salary, while high, is a fraction of corporate CEO pay—MTN’s CEO earned R74 million in 2023. Yet public sector roles carry unique pressures: accountability to taxpayers, not shareholders. Kieswetter’s pay must be weighed against his impact, not just numbers.
Rebuilding SARS: Kieswetter’s Turnaround Triumph
Kieswetter’s leadership since 2019 is a masterclass in institutional revival. He faced a SARS crippled by state capture, with outdated technology and demoralized staff. His strategy was multi-pronged: restore trust, modernize systems, and crack down on noncompliance. The results speak volumes.
Revenue Collection
In 2023/24, SARS collected R1.7 trillion, up 8.3% from R1.57 trillion the prior year. This outpaced GDP growth (0.6%, Stats SA), defying economic headwinds. Kieswetter’s focus on compliance—leveraging data analytics and voluntary disclosure programs—drove results. For businesses, this signals tighter scrutiny. Taxpayers must prioritize accurate filings to avoid audits.
Illicit Trade Crackdowns
Illicit trade, especially tobacco, was a bleeding wound. Kieswetter formed a dedicated unit, handling 1,230 cases by 2024. The unit raised R80 billion in assessments, collecting R36 billion. Tobacco alone yielded R20 billion in assessments, with R4 billion collected. These efforts cut illicit cigarette trade to 58% by 2023, down from 60% in 2020. Businesses in high-risk sectors (e.g., tobacco, alcohol) should brace for stricter enforcement.
Technology and Staff Morale
Kieswetter invested in digital platforms, streamlining tax filings and audits. SARS’s eFiling system now processes 90% of returns digitally, per the 2023/24 report. He also prioritized staff. Regular town halls and transparent leadership rebuilt morale. For leaders, this underscores the power of visibility and communication in turnarounds.
Challenges Remain
Economic stagnation and tax evasion persist. SARS faces budget constraints, limiting hiring and tech upgrades. Yet Kieswetter’s vision—a “SMART Modern SARS”—is taking shape. His ability to deliver under pressure justifies his high salary to supporters.
Public Sentiment and Ethical Questions
Kieswetter’s R11.71 million salary sparked heated debate. On X, users expressed mixed views. Some praised his results: “R1.7T in taxes? Pay the man!” Others decried inequality: “R11M while teachers earn R300K? Shameful.” South Africa’s economic divide fuels this tension. The median annual income is R48,000 (Stats SA, 2023), making Kieswetter’s pay seem astronomical.
Ethically, high public sector salaries raise questions. Should leaders of critical institutions earn private-sector wages? Kieswetter’s defenders argue his expertise commands a premium—losing him to the private sector would cost more. Critics counter that public service demands modesty, especially in a struggling economy. The debate isn’t just about Kieswetter—it’s about fairness in a fractured society.
FAQs
Why is Edward Kieswetter’s salary so high?
His R11.71 million reflects his expertise, results (R1.7T in revenue), and private-sector benchmarks. Critics argue it’s excessive given inequality.
How does SARS justify his pay?
SARS ties compensation to performance. Kieswetter’s turnaround—record revenue, illicit trade crackdowns—supports his salary.
What’s in his salary package?
Likely base pay (R8-9M), bonuses for revenue targets, and pension benefits, per public sector norms.
How does his pay compare?
It exceeds Eskom’s CEO (R7.1M) but trails corporate CEOs (e.g., MTN’s R74M). It aligns with turnaround specialists.
Can businesses expect tougher tax enforcement?
Yes. SARS’s data-driven audits and illicit trade units signal stricter compliance. File accurately and disclose errors early.
Most Expensive Restaurant in South Africa: La Colombe
Conclusion: Weighing Edward Kieswetter’s Salary
Edward Kieswetter’s salary of R11.71 million is more than a number. It’s a symbol of South Africa’s complex realities—rewarding excellence amid inequality. His leadership transformed SARS, delivering R1.7 trillion in revenue and curbing illicit trade. For professionals, his story offers clear lessons: stay compliant, lead with purpose, and plan finances wisely. Debate his pay, but not his impact. Apply these insights to navigate taxes, lead teams, and thrive in a challenging economy.
Get the latest entrepreneurial success stories, expert tips, and exclusive updates delivered straight to your inbox — Sign up for Entrepreneur Hub SA’s newsletter today!
